Discuss mailing list

[Alejandro Bonet <albogoal AT gmail.com>]

In the early times of internet, the rule for dns was FIRST COME FIRST "OWN".

(Perhaps with the adding rule of "if they are doing a good work in time...")

This is only a namespace... Thats all!!

If ICANN will replace .free or .ing, i understand this is the war.

And in the war anybody can do whatever they want...

For example: Elevate this discussion to The Public, and let people
knows whats the matter.

In worldwide TVs, newspapers and all the internet.

Must be tlds registration democratic or will be sold by a central
authority who does not respect previous names and creates conflicts?

Who creates conflicts?
Who wants a babel internet?
Who wants to split internet names space?

Alejandro Bonet
md.es.dns.opennic.glue

PD: IMHO if a tld has more than five letters/digits, dont conflict
with previous ICANN or OPENNIC (or another public DNS services we can
see) and dont spoof popular names
(like cocacola), then OpenNIC must aprove it directly and
automatically, if it has a valid dns server and a registry web with an
uptime greater than 80%.

If it has 2 letters/digits, then only approved if it is for ethnics.

If it has 3 or 4 letters/digits, then democratically (and perhaps
designing randomly A JURY
of OpenNIC members to study the case, and to avoid disturb all the
members all the time with all the tlds...)

It is only my opinion, but the thing is very very important...

We need a "good machine for approval tlds"...

If we dont build it, some other will do, and capital will own internet...

If ICANN has only a rule "You must have 100.000 US$",
internet will not be free and open no more.

For the opennic members who has a ICANN caused conflict (like .free or
.ing) a sugerence:
Sure your users their sld names will be respected if changes the tld
(like .free2 or .ing2)

As time passes every body in this planet will see who are the bad guys
in this story...

And who are doing a good work.


2013/7/31, Pavel Volkov <negaipub AT gmail.com>:
> On Wednesday 31 July 2013 10:21:19 Julian DeMarchi wrote:
>> Will fix for you sir.
>
> There also another issue with reg.for.free I encountered.
> I registered gundam.geek domain and try to add an MX record.
> The problem is "Domain name" text area on the add/update record page.
> The website says:
> "examples include mail and mx01"
>
> Ok, it allows to enter "mail". However, if I type "gundam.geek." there, it
> reports "Invalid Domain Name entered".
>
> Am I doing something wrong? If not so, please fix :)
>
>
> --------
> You are a member of the OpenNIC Discuss list.
> You may unsubscribe by emailing
> discuss-unsubscribe AT lists.opennicproject.org
>