Discuss mailing list

[Erich Eckner <opennic AT eckner.net>]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA256

Hi,

it seems your deployment is not complete:

The charter on https://opennic.marathi/ points at tld.marathi (web and 
mail), which has neither A, AAAA nor MX records. Did you mean 
opennic.marathi, like you write in your email? opennic.marathi resolves 
for A, but has no MX record either - those mails cannot possibly arrive.

Besides this, your proposal looks good to me.

reagards,
Erich

On Thu, 6 May 2021, Ninad Chandorkar wrote:

> Hey there! 
> I am Nenadd Chandorkar, a full-time system administrator and an
> entrepreneur. I run a web hosting business in Maharashtra, India. I want to
> come up with .marathi TLD for Marathi speaking crowd of Maharashtra, India. 
>
> This TLD will be useful for commercial and non-commercial purposes. My plan
> is to bring 97% of small and medium businesses online by providing free TLD
> and IPFS based hosting. 
>
> I already have already done my compliance for the TLD. 
>
> 1. Tier 1 DNS Server (Unlisted) - Status: Done [
> http://report.opennicproject.org/t2log/t1.php?ip_addr=103.138.238.10 ] 
>
> 2. Tier 2 DNS Server - Status: Done [
> http://report.opennicproject.org/t2log/t2.php?ip_addr=103.138.238.151 ] 
>
> 3. Administration Team - Status: Done 
>
> 4. Website with Charter and other information- Status: Done [
> http://opennic.marathi ] (Currently running only in our data center) 
>
> 5. Administrative Emails - Status: Done 
> i) hostmaster AT opennic.marathi 
> ii) abuse AT opennic.marathi 
> iii) webmaster AT opennic.marathi 
>
> 6. Our policies are in line with Opennic's Policies (Attaching Charter
> below)
>
>  DEADLINE FOR VOTEING WILL BE 14TH MAY 2021 12.00 AM UTC (7 DAYS FROM
> POSTING) 
>
> ------ Charter ------ 
>
> .marathi TLD 
>
>
> The .marathi TLD, operated by the HostingDuty administration, is to be used
> by commercial and non-commercial entities (individual or groups) to promote
> themselves on the OpenNIC free network.
>
>  This domain is intended to be used in a general sense, akin to .com in the
> ICANN network, and as such has a very general use case and little
> restrictions on registration. Registration is available on a first-come,
> first-serve basis. Charter Please see www.hostingduty.com/charter for the
> most up-to-date version of this charter. The .marathi TLD, operated by the
> HostingDuty administration, is to be used by commercial and non-commercial
> entities (individual or groups) to promote themselves on the OpenNIC free
> network. This domain is intended to be used in a general sense, akin to .com
> in the ICANN network, and as such has a very general use case and little
> restrictions on registration. Use of this TLD is not a given right to any
> holder, and domain names may be revoked by the HostingDuty administration
> team or by a vote of domain holders (henceforth known as “Members”),
> especially pertaining to violations of our policies (see Section 2).
> “Members” in this charter refers to owners of .marathi domains and not
> OpenNIC members unless otherwise noted. Registration “.marathi” domains will
> be available on a first-come, first-serve basis. Some domains have been
> reserved for administrative use (see Section 6) prior to public
> registration. Registrations immediately after approval will be handled
> manually via email. An automated registration system is in development and
> will be available at tld.marathi when it becomes available. Registrations
> will be available from 3 month to 10 year periods. All registrations will be
> available for free after approval, however, the HostingDuty administration
> holds the right to raise prices as needed to cover operating costs. Abuse
> HostingDuty will not tolerate the following behaviour, and use of our
> domains for any of the following is grounds for termination: * - Domain
> squatting - Spam email delivery - Malware distribution - Malicious
> interference with computer systems Our abuse policies are in line with
> OpenNIC’s abuse policies as well (http://wiki.opennicproject.org/TLDPolicy –
> “Obnoxious Activity: Spam & Cracking”), and any policies listed there apply
> to “.marathi” domains as well. 
>
> The HostingDuty registry/administration is not a domain police force and
> meaningful abuse enforcement will be reliant on members reporting. All
> abusive behaviour should be immediately reported to abuse AT tld.marathi so
> administration can take action. Termination Domains can be immediately
> terminated if they are found to be in violation of our policies by the
> HostingDuty administration, and a notice will be sent to the registrant of
> the offending domain. Domains can also be terminated via a member vote.
> Membership is granted to any domain holder, 1 vote per member regardless of
> the amount registrations they hold. Member votes are subject to policies as
> listed in Section 4. Domains may also be revoked by the HostingDuty
> administration if the OpenNIC membership at large moves to revoke a
> registration. 
>
> We do not foresee a circumstance where OpenNIC as a whole will be required
> to vote on the revocation of a .marathi domain, but if the need arises we
> will comply with any such vote. 
>
> Disputes Trademark holders should email trademarks AT tld.marathi if they wish
> to dispute a domain. HostingDuty will revoke or transfer registrations if
> ordered by a legitimate court of law, as a courtesy to that country, as
> applicable to OpenNIC’s dispute policy. 
>
> Amendments 
>
> Amendments to this charter may be added by a vote of .marathi domain
> holders. Additionally, the HostingDuty administration is permitted to
> provide a binding user agreement for registrations at tld.marathi that may
> include policies outside the scope of this charter. 
>
> Policies Please see https://hostingduty.com/marathi-policy for the most
> up-to-date organizational policies regarding this TLD. .marathi generally
> accepts any OpenNIC policies regarding abuse. The activities we prohibit
> include, but are not limited to: domain squatting, spam email delivery,
> malware distribution, or malicious interference with computer systems. 
>
> Contacts 
> • Website: hostingduty.com / tld.marathi 
> • Administrator: ninad AT hostingduty.com 
> • Other Contact: support AT hostingduty.com 
>
> Regards 
>
> Nenadd Chandorkar
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
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=lvOy
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----