Discuss mailing list

[Jeff Taylor <shdwdrgn AT sourpuss.net>]

    Oddly your server got moved back to waiting for approval.  I'm not
    even sure how that happened, but I've reactivated it so you should
    be good to go now.

On 11/30/21 08:50, R4SAS wrote:

    On 2021-11-21
      07:24, Jeff Taylor wrote:
      
> Sorry for the late reply, but I can
>         explain what happened.  Basically
>         
>         we had an issue with the LDAP servers awhile back which was
>         causing a
>         
>         number of servers to be marked as offline incorrectly.  So what
>         I did
>         
>         was shut down the code that auto-removed servers for being
>         offline.
>         
>         So all of the servers were continuously tested even though they
>         were
>         
>         failing to respond.
>         
>         
>         The a few weeks ago I re-enabled the auto-removal code to clean
>         up all
>         
>         the servers that were still failing to respond.  There was a
>         huge drop
>         
>         in the list of active servers, but the ones that were removed
>         simply
>         
>         weren't responding to any queries.
>         
>         
>         If for some reason one of your servers were removed when they
>         should
>         
>         still be active, let me know.  They should still be listed under
>         that
>         
>         "X" group and I can restore them from there, or tell you what
>         aspect
>         
>         is failing the testing and caused your server to be dropped.
>         
>         
>         On 11/19/21 21:10, Tim C wrote:
>         
>         
> > I'm not an an OpenNic admin, so I am
> >           just surmising.
> >           
> >           Stats when logged into servers.opennic.org:
> >           
> >           
> >           Aprv: 1
> >           
> >           Ok: 10
> >           
> >           Err: 4
> >           
> >           Dis: 22
> >           
> >           Rm: 23
> >           
> >           X: 217
> >           
> >           Total: 60
> >           
> >           
> >           Entirely possible something is going wrong on the opennic
> >           side.
> >           
> >           This tweaked my interest so I did a quick audit of every IP in
> >           the
> >           
> >           "Deleted" list. 17 of the 217 are (currently) working
> >           
> >           
> >           When investigating the "X" (deleted) set of servers: 117 of
> >           them all
> >           
> >           show "No longer listed since Oct 12, 22:50 UTC (5 weeks, 3
> >           days)".
> >           
> >           with 122 having the same added date: "2021-Sep-09"
> >           
> >           
> >           So something probably happened in Oct.
> >           
> >           
> >           On 11/19/21 00:21, Lennart Seitz wrote:
> >           
> >           Hi Tim,
> >           
> >           
> >           I’m also interested why server been removed and can assure you
> >           
> >           that at
> >           
> >           least mine were running the entire time (e.g. no 48 hours
> >           downtime
> >           
> >           in a
> >           
> >           row), also the amount of servers seem unreasonable high for
> >           this
> >           
> >           kind of
> >           
> >           removal.
> >           
> >           
> >           The list had similar problems in the past, maybe the
> >           webserverlist
> >           
> >           itself was offline and falsely diagnosed T2 as offline?
> >           
> >           
> >           Regards,
> >           
> >           Lennart
> >           
> >           
> >           On 17.11.2021 22:58, Tim C wrote:
> >           
> >           On 17/11/21 04:08, Echedey Lopez Romero wrote:
> >           
> >           Good afternoon.
> >           
> >           
> >           I already asked this in the IRC group at Libera.Chat and told
> >           me to
> >           
> >           ask
> >           
> >           here instead.
> >           
> >           
> >           So, I have seen in the last months how several OpenNIC Tier 2
> >           
> >           servers
> >           
> >           get removed from the list. What is happening?
> >           
> >           
> >           From memory, a fair amount of them were just down. As it is up
> >           to
> >           
> >           the
> >           
> >           community to keep them running.
> >           
> >           
> >           After 48 hours of being "down" they are moved to a pending
> >           deletion
> >           
> >           status. Which is what is shown at the bottom of:
> >           
> >           https://servers.opennic.org/
> >           
> >           
> >           Cheers
> >           
> >         
>         
>         --------
>         
>         You are a member of the OpenNIC Discuss list.
>         
>         You may unsubscribe by emailing
>         
>         discuss-unsubscribe AT lists.opennicproject.org
>         
>         
>         --------
>         
>         You are a member of the OpenNIC Discuss list.
>         
>         You may unsubscribe by emailing
>         
>         discuss-unsubscribe AT lists.opennicproject.org
>         
>         
>         
>         --------
>         
>         You are a member of the OpenNIC Discuss list.
>         
>         You may unsubscribe by emailing
>         discuss-unsubscribe AT lists.opennicproject.org
>         
>       
      
      Just found that this problem happend to my server too. Asking
      about re-approval of ns8.fr.dns.opennic.glue.
      
      Jeff, maybe re-checking in DELETED state can be added? Because
      such deletion when validation server can't connect with other due
      to software/networking issue when server really works for other
      users is really wrong idea. For example, I haven't problems about
      reaching my server for 2 months (since I added my server to
      DNSCrypt lists), but I got removed here without any
      notifications...
      
      
      

--------
You are a member of the OpenNIC Discuss list. 
You may unsubscribe by emailing discuss-unsubscribe AT lists.opennicproject.org