Discuss mailing list

[Peter Green <peter AT greenpete.free>]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA256

It's just occured to me that despite someone (I think Brian) sending this 
proposed new T.L.D. conversation over to the discus list where it belongs, 
it's come back to the op's list. Maybe I replied to the wrong message...

So here are my thoughts on the 'charter' for the proposed new T.L.D. .ibu




- -------- Original Message --------
From: Peter Green <peter AT greenpete.free>
Sent: Thu Jan 16 19:52:44 GMT 2014
To: dns-operations AT lists.opennicproject.org
Subject: Re: [opennic-dns-operations] Please, resolve .ibu domains


> 0.- These three persons DECIDE how and because to resolve conflicts
> in the .ibu namespace by unanimity. If they can't reach unanimity
> to resolve a conflict, the decissions are made by vote of the
> general assembly of all domain owners with the basis of one vote
> for each physical person. The target of these three persons will be
> allways to avoid any kind of conflicts, and if they are
> unavoidable, to try to resolve them with impartiality. These three
> persons are not chairmans or presidents, else they are judges: They
> only act when there are problems. All their decissions will be
> publically accessible and commentable.
>

> 1.- Official language here is español, and the second language is
> english.

Is this point ok with OpenNIC? It is mainly an English speaking
network with English only mailing lists (and I.R.C?)

I have mixed feeling on it myself.


> 2.- .ibu domains are public to the internet.

What exactly does this mean? Given that all OpenNIC T.L.D's are public.


> 3.- Everybody can register all .ibu domains they want, without
> limits in quantity.


> 4.- Dictionary based abuses will be automatically prosecuted and
> deleted.


> 5.- Unfair domains (like cocacola.ibu) are not accepted if you are
> not the owner of the trade mark.


> 6.- Very generic domains (like music.ibu) could be denied if they
> don't have fair content.

Why? That sounds a little dictatorial, who decides what is 'fair content?

> 7.- The service is free first year, and then cost ten ibus per
> year.

> 8.- If the domain serves an ibu1000 node (an ibu currency bank
> accepting ibu transfers) it is free forever.


> 9.- The service includes a basic dns service to add resource
> records (NS, A, AAAA, MX, etc) with unlimited subdomains. Also
> includes a http redirection service.

This doesn't seem to be relevant to a charter, more simply a service
that is offered.


> 10.- The registry web is at http://registro.ibu

It says on the main OpenNIC website that the registrations page should
be at opennic.TLD
http://www.opennicproject.org/opennic-policies/creating-a-tld/

> 11.- All the .ibu second level domains will be aliased as third
> level domains under ibu1000.net, for example: jiminycricket.ibu =
> jiminycricket.ibu1000.net

Interesting idea! :-)

> 12.- We will concentrate efforts to get public dns servers around
> the world recognize and resolve .ibu domains.

Again, is this a relevant part of a charter?


> 13.- To change this declaration (charter=acta), the complete new
> propossed version of this text will be publically accessible and
> commentable, and each .ibu domain owner will have a vote.

Will the OpenNIC membership notified about such changes as well as
.ibu domain owners?

I would personally be happier if the charter was in 'good English'
i.e. translated properly so we can evaluate it better.

These are my thoughts and questions, please, anyone feel free to
comment on them should you wish.

Peter
- ----
To unsubscribe, email dns-operations-unsubscribe AT lists.opennicproject.org



-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: APG v1.0.9

iQFBBAEBCAArBQJS2GpyJBxQZXRlciBHcmVlbiA8cGV0ZXJAZ3JlZW5wZXRlLmNv
LnVrPgAKCRDwSqngs+9nOdjuB/9zPuHTNozloqc0dznk7HOXurciyOhHoPcriYAE
KBn8l1IDenQ7IKSPDNhXzNpyrHhQAWvlI9wi0aOm1Xg24jMHDza9nJcVTLUqO/eH
es+FFycXRgTZx1m0AxiHB4FzAW+RPtWCqzAY6ufCOSB3gIb5mGd2JbpLnBogUK4L
cYhrgYkONeCBjbiP3QxUM2C6eglh+FFBJ+KLiHHJSWAAcxwp3SRl2Bi5MVIxc9nt
tbieh54Li7jTpKe6uvgIDyEMkoeb0kgLEJIyjXdBNjHObvAGPhvwx7tXn/xgI2a6
SK4isX8gckrb4FMfvR+XRGNz9HsTLp2qxhY5IaT+mhD6QRUr
=YAJz
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----