Discuss mailing list

["Dmitry S. Nikolaev" <dn AT mega-net.ru>]

Hi.

On 22.10.2017 06:57, Jonah Aragon wrote:

What were you thinking? Did you have any specific things in mind you wanted to see here?

I`am glad to see that someone try to wrote more clear and detailed rules for TLD registering process.

On 21.10.2017 23:27, Jonah Aragon wrote:

Section V: DNS Server Operator Requirements

.......skiped.....

Tier 1 Operators:

- MUST operate their server indefinitely.

- SHOULD be available on the #opennic IRC channel on Freenode, for immediate alerts to issues that may be time-sensitive.

.......skiped.....

Tier 2 Operators:

.......skiped.....

- SHOULD NOT operate from a country that censors web content.

- OPTIONALLY be available on the #opennic IRC channel on Freenode, for immediate alerts to issues that may be time-sensitive.

For my opinion this options are too severely.
"indefinitely" - what do you mean ? persom can`t leave if he want ?
Also it's not always possible to be present in the IRC.
Many countries now impose restrictions on content in one way or another.

With best regards, Dmitry S. Nikolaev
virus_net