Dns-operations mailing list

[mike <mike AT pikeaero.com>]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Travis,

I am sorry but I would tend to disagree on this.

What if a person is mostly not doing inter-web for instance? One might
be doing p2p development or ssh/telnet (.bbs for instance does a lot
of that), I think it's more troublesome to troubleshoot if you send
back the wrong IP address than if you simply don't respond.

I understand the argument for the redirecting, I just speak from
experience that it can be a frustrating and time consuming issue to
debug when you observer that you can ping "domain.tld" but your
application does not seem to be able to connect to the port you are
expecting to be able to connect to, only to eventually discover that
you are being handed the wrong IP address by the DNS resolver.

I think that a good solution to the somewhat transient nature of the
OpenNIC resolver pool is a client-side resolver evaluator along the
lines of http://sourceforge.net/projects/opennicwizard/ although I am
a little partial toward that particular effort. I am suggesting that the
transient nature of the resolver pool seems to ask for a client-side
solution that is adaptable to resolvers coming and going, until we can
get a lot more OpenNIC-friendly ISPs on board.

PS. I currently do not advocate using OpenNICWizard in a production
environment, although it is working quite well in many regards, it is
still in development. Also, for those who have been waiting, another
OpenNICWizard release is due out shortly, I freely admit that I am
guilty of slacking, sorry.

- --Mike

On 05/16/2012 03:39 AM, Travis McCrea wrote:
> Before a server is removed from service, I feel the T2 operator
> should redirect all queries to a page telling them that their DNS
> server will be disabled soon and that they should use new servers…
> this way people don't just have their DNS queries just stop
> responding Travis McCrea Deputy Leader, Pirate Party of Canada 
> Chief Administrative Officer, Pirate Parties International Captain,
> United States Pirate Party (PNC) Member, Washington State Pirate
> Party
> 
> Canada: 1(778)709-4859 US: 1(206)552-8728
> 
> Twitter: @TeamColtra Facebook: fb.me/teamcoltra Blog:
> http://travismccrea.com
> 
> The views expressed in this email represent my own personal values
> and not the values of the Pirate Party, the Pirate Ideology, or any
> of my associations.
> 
> On 2012-05-15, at 5:29 AM, Jon Plews wrote:
> 
>> Hi,
>> 
>> Please remove 89.16.173.11 from the server lists, it will be
>> going away by the end of the year. It is being replaced by
>> 213.138.101.252
>> 
>> Regards
>> 
>> Jon
> 
> 

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.11 (GNU/Linux)
Comment: Using GnuPG with Mozilla - http://enigmail.mozdev.org/

iQEcBAEBAgAGBQJPs++NAAoJEA7EcEr0emgfQ9sIAIjqm9K+XcEd2cf1M58SXMxE
MtVp670XVGkNuHdiYgtCNe8TJt1suGf7wuy9LPTagFS/OBsAhIUQOZBVp+Ic0afn
z4G+c983Q0dyaCPWDOM95MzPPCtOD3kLNrQQWB42fq7CC/O8gJsTbxjV9f3WaU0z
TF8j8T/s+07dTNCXjMOyeJf2I1Y8SMaLGj1PKHn+edGEvRrcQ4xXH9spbgkmnkd8
XNB+IPzoPnSsZlr89+HTRTOlfD8U8C7ucqKMfbUm7fpcM23siOK9pT1Os4QOgOqe
EbDYHHoyqbhHvvCzAZOBqgtYZW8eOrhzC+rUnatThe/sRHNGCUsNd6VbQiKJnSY=
=4mSL
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----