Discuss mailing list

[Philipp Schafft <lion AT lion.leolix.org>]

Good afternoon,

On Tue, 2018-08-21 at 20:53 -0400, Daniel Quintiliani wrote:
> Yes (6):
> 
> Daniel Quintiliani
> Jonah Aragon
> Allen Schultz
> Dennis Emory Hannon
> Jacob Bachmeyer
> Vladimir F.
> 
> No (7):
> 
> Amunak
> Megan Parat
> Jack Ternan
> Sebastian Makowiecki*
> vv
> kevin
> Al Beano*
> 
> Invalid votes:
> 
> Philipp Schafft ("democracy")
> 
> * changed from invalid vote
> 
> Proposal failed to pass, 6-7

I can not second this counting as I come to a different counting.

I count as following:

Yes:
      * Vladimir F. <geek AT nabitw.xyz> in
        <15a5a48a-086b-bef3-8d90-06c01db6fe29 AT nabitw.xyz>
      * Allen Schultz <allen.schultz AT gmail.com> in <CAP+RUJfu
        +eFMWuwE7oKE-24SC9BQzyZS6gddqD2x_VZbOC53sQ AT mail.gmail.com>
      * Dennis Emory Hannon <info AT backplanedns.org> in
        <c30d9b4e-4126-2846-b2c0-b8aaaaeb9049 AT backplanedns.org>
      * Jacob Bachmeyer <jcb62281 AT gmail.com> in
        <5B78A264.2030600 AT gmail.com>
      * Jonah Aragon <jonah AT opennic.org> in
        <D48868E0-C33D-4EC4-B1D8-6C2FD79D69D8 AT opennic.org>
      * Daniel Quintiliani <danq AT runbox.com> in
        <E1fpjuH-0005gz-ER AT rmmprod07.runbox>

No:
      * Amunak <amunak AT amunak.net> in
        <97fc7d61-b0b6-4e0e-ce8f-4fb7e0b92e60 AT amunak.net>
      * Megan Parat <megan.parat AT yahoo.com> in
        <b47fcfe7-fc59-4340-3eab-dfbb4a0417b4 AT yahoo.com>
      * Jack Ternan <jackist AT email.com> in
        
<trinity-42ea374d-b4f4-49c3-b0ee-10010f652460-1534647456998@3c-app-mailcom-lxa13>
      * vv AT cgs.pw in <20180819005723.09dd06b1@SCO>
      * kevin <krattai AT gmail.com> in
        <1534680795.30790.0.camel AT gmail.com>

Spoilt:
      * Philipp Schafft <lion AT lion.leolix.org> in
        <1534336345.5822.21.camel AT lion.leolix.org>
      * Al Beano <albino AT autistici.org> in
        <fe497fa4-8e95-4e5b-930d-87eaea53168a AT autistici.org>
      * Al Beano <albino AT autistici.org> in
        <c1f25b84-2c8e-57ee-0b53-eb1928ebc5ed AT autistici.org> (invalid as
        double voted)
      * Sebastian Makowiecki <soocki AT mailbox.org> in
        <B8665C93-F951-437B-BBD3-BBE5AB7112E8 AT mailbox.org>
      * Sebastian Makowiecki <soocki AT mailbox.org> in
        <B41391A6-0328-44E0-ADFA-8A656C8CD965 AT mailbox.org> (invalid as
        double voted)

Total counts:
Yes: 6; No: 5; Spoilt: 3; TOTAL: 14

Relative counts:
Yes: 6/14 = ~42.86%; No: 5/14 = ~35.71%; Spoilt: 3/14 = ~21.43%

Therefore:
Yes wins with highest number of votes.


I ask someone to step up and do a 3rd counting.


With best regards,


> On Tue, 14 Aug 2018 20:41:29 -0400 (EDT), "Daniel Quintiliani" 
> <danq AT runbox.com> wrote:
> 
> > Voting starts: 8/15/2018 0040 UTC
> > Voting ends 8/22/2018 0040 UTC
> > 
> > 1. All OpenNIC proposals put up for vote shall be in the English language.
> > 2. All votes for OpenNIC proposals shall be in the English language, and 
> > votes which are not in English shall be considered invalid.
> > 
> > These rules are only applicable to proposals put up for vote, and to the 
> > votes themselves. These rules are not applicable to discussions on the 
> > mailing list or on IRC.
> > 
> > The proposal shall take effect immediately after passing.
> > 
> > This vote shall be done in "Aye/Yes" and "Nay/No" style. Only English 
> > language votes shall be accepted.


-- 
Philipp.
 (Rah of PH2)