Discuss mailing list

[Zach Gibbens <infocop411 AT gmail.com>]

If I was from Britanny, ran a personal site, not racist, for profit, or
even rude, would that be allowed? my site may talk about where I'm from,
covering culture, or not, just a kid/geeks personal site, a blog

The way I read it, was unclear (the grey area being hard to see if it
was allowed (white) or against (black) your proposed charted) I'd
suggest making that clear, might help things take off quicker, and since
it still has the relationship to brittany, could still cause a travelers
curiosity.

From your last email, I see what your intent is, from your charter,
harder to see, I think it's fine. perhaps dropping netiquette for
hate-speech and racism is forbidden.

I like it, just making sure I understood it too

On 26/02/11 18:58, Cédric wrote:
> Our only goal with these limitations (netiquette, non-commercial) was to 
> protect the .BZH from any kind of racism, profit-use, and so on ... but, 
> it's just like all the charters : it's a sort of guideline, not a law with 
> the associated control you could imagine.
> 
> It never was our intention to artificially limit the use of the .BZH. So if 
> you think theses limitations can bring some kind of "censorship", "stylish 
> guide", or "only politically correct sites" (sorry for the word-to-word 
> translate from the french, hope this is understandable), we can remove 
> them. As I already said before, no problem for us.
> 
> Cédric
> 
> Le 27 févr. 2011 à 00:19, Jeff Taylor a écrit :
> 
>> I don't see where you are reading any rules regarding ethics?  The way I 
>> read his original charter, it sounds like they are focusing on discussion 
>> that relates to a particular culture and/or region.
>>
>> As for the ads and donation buttons... to me this is just trying to limit 
>> sites that are *intentionally* for-profit.  I agree it could use some 
>> clarification to avoid future disagreements, but it doesn't sound like he 
>> is trying to limit donations to a website that are funding either the site 
>> hosting or a cause that the site is promoting.  Maybe Cedric can provide 
>> more clarification on this, and we can help suggest rules that are more 
>> specific?
>>
> 
> 
> 
> _______________________________________________
> discuss mailing list
> discuss AT lists.opennicproject.org
> http://lists.darkdna.net/mailman/listinfo/discuss

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature